Computer image analysis of two-dimensional crystals of beef heart NADH: ubiquinone oxidoreductase fragments. I. Comparison of crystal structures in various negative stains.

We investigated the structure of two-dimensional crystals from bovine heart mitochondrial NADH: ubiquinone oxidoreductase. A detailed description of uranyl acetate-stained crystals demonstrated that they are composed of fragments in a spatial arrangement according to space group P4212 [J. Brink, S. Hovmöller, C.I. Ragan, M.W.J. Cleeter, E.J. Boekema and E.F.J. van Bruggen, European J. Biochem. 166 (1987) 287]. To gain more structural information on the crystal structure and to assess the effects of various negative stains on the structure preservation and appearance, we examined stained crystals by means of electron microscopy and image analysis. The space group P4212 appeared to be present for several stains tested, i.e. ammonium molybdate, uranyl acetate, uranyl nitrate and uranyl sulphate. Use of phosphotungstic acid and silicotungstate resulted in a reduction of symmetry to pseudo-P4212 or p4. Use of sodium tungstate led to a considerable loss of resolution to 3.8 nm at best, whereas otherwise 1.5 to 1.9 nm could be demonstrated. The lattice vectors were not affected by the stains; they were determined as a = b = 14.9 +/- 0.25 nm with gamma = 89.8 degrees +/- 0.6 degrees. Image analysis showed the presence of similar structures with the molybdate and uranyl compounds. Differences were observed in the case of the tungstate type of stains. Furthermore, the analysis revealed the complete absence of the four small pores of 2.0 nm diameter in the unit cell. This effect was observed irrespective of the type of stain and supporting film, and could be ascribed only to the glow-discharge treatment of the supporting film. The observed difference must be caused by changed interactions between the protein, stain and supporting film. Application of correspondence analysis and clustering algorithms to the various reconstructed images of the crystals showed that they could be separated into several clusters. Each of these clusters corresponded on the average to only one type of stain, whereas a further division according to the specific uranyl compounds was observed. This study therefore shows that under identical preparation conditions subtle differences between individual stains can be detected.