Abstract
The effect of screening with prostate-specific-antigen (PSA) testing and digital rectal examination on the rate of death from prostate cancer is unknown. This is the first report from the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal, and Ovarian (PLCO) Cancer Screening Trial on prostate-cancer mortality. From 1993 through 2001, we randomly assigned 76,693 men at 10 U.S. study centers to receive either annual screening (38,343 subjects) or usual care as the control (38,350 subjects). Men in the screening group were offered annual PSA testing for 6 years and digital rectal examination for 4 years. The subjects and health care providers received the results and decided on the type of follow-up evaluation. Usual care sometimes included screening, as some organizations have recommended. The numbers of all cancers and deaths and causes of death were ascertained. In the screening group, rates of compliance were 85% for PSA testing and 86% for digital rectal examination. Rates of screening in the control group increased from 40% in the first year to 52% in the sixth year for PSA testing and ranged from 41 to 46% for digital rectal examination. After 7 years of follow-up, the incidence of prostate cancer per 10,000 person-years was 116 (2820 cancers) in the screening group and 95 (2322 cancers) in the control group (rate ratio, 1.22; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.16 to 1.29). The incidence of death per 10,000 person-years was 2.0 (50 deaths) in the screening group and 1.7 (44 deaths) in the control group (rate ratio, 1.13; 95% CI, 0.75 to 1.70). The data at 10 years were 67% complete and consistent with these overall findings. After 7 to 10 years of follow-up, the rate of death from prostate cancer was very low and did not differ significantly between the two study groups. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00002540.)
MeSH Terms
Aged
Digital Rectal Examination/adverse effects
Follow-Up Studies
Humans
Incidence
Male
Mass Screening/adverse effects
Middle Aged
Patient Compliance
Prostate-Specific Antigen/blood
Prostatic Neoplasms/diagnosis,epidemiology,mortality
United States/epidemiology
Chemicals
Prostate-Specific Antigen
Authors & Affiliations
25 authors, click to expand affiliations / ORCID
Andriole Gerald L
Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, USA.
Crawford E David
Grubb Robert L
Buys Saundra S
Chia David
Church Timothy R
Fouad Mona N
Gelmann Edward P
Kvale Paul A
Reding Douglas J
Weissfeld Joel L
Yokochi Lance A
O'Brien Barbara
Clapp Jonathan D
Rathmell Joshua M
Riley Thomas L
Hayes Richard B
Kramer Barnett S
Izmirlian Grant
Miller Anthony B
Pinsky Paul F
Prorok Philip C
Gohagan John K
Berg Christine D
PLCO Project Team
Investigators
783 investigators, click to expand
Berg Christine D
Gohagan John K
Prorok Philip C
Hsing Ann W
Lacey James V
Purdue Mark
Hayes Richard B
Simpson Nancy K
Cumberlin Richard
Rossi Susan
Zhu Claire
Huang Wen-Yi
Marquez Guillermo
Browne Joyce E H
Hoffman Susan
Coleman Dorothy M
Jackson Charles
Lange Erin
McMillan Dorothy
Papadopoulos Evantha
Sylver-Foust Desiree
Sullivan Dorothy
Brown Martin
Gaegler Jennifer
Gray Linda
Greenwald Peter
Fraumeni Joseph F
Fagerstrom Richard M
Hu Ping
Izmirlian Grant
Levin David L
Pinsky Paul
Xu Jian-Lun
Kreimer Aimee
Marcus Pamela M
Subar Amy F
Black Amanda
Hartge Patricia
Hoover Robert N
Ziegler Regina G
Costlow Richard
Laine Andrew F
Miller Anthony B
Pearson Dinah
van Nagell John R
Stallings Fred L
Miller Daniel S
Kramer Barnett S
Chia David
Dry Sarah
Seligson David
Terasaki Paul
Reiss Jean
Tze Sheila
Acalinovich Andrew
Besada Stefan
Chan Henry
Cheung-Lau Gardenia
Corbett Shaun
Durongwong Patty
Eeva Mervi
Folayan Labo
Gruebel Bianca
Habeeb Omar
Huynh Kiet
Kanegai Cindy
Kim Helen
Kim Sarang
Ko Ara
Kohlmeier Sean
Lamb Cassandra
Lu Marianne
Martin June
Maynard Scott
Noravian Fred
Schirrippa Osvaldo
Padilla Gabriel
Rumbin Alexis
Shevlin Linda
Ty Rica
Wang Qun
Wong Joanne
Xu Shuang
Yu Hong
Koci Janis
Kopp William
Rager Helen
Smith Craig
Roser Dave
Cahill Jack
O'Brien Barbara
Gardner Susan
Carrick Danielle
Yurgalevitch Susan
Dunn Marsha
Bailey Cheryl
Bodenstein Yancy
Burr Peggy
Caughman Cindy
Cutrin Jacqueline
Eisen Joseph
Frias Amena
Glashofer Sara
Hurtmullen Kathy
Kavounis Katie
Ke Polly
Khanani Fauzia
Laimon Benjamin
Mechanic Leah
Menacker Fay
Mesnard Mary
Nichaman Leah
Novey Shama
Palace Cindy
Peace Steve
Pettit Karen
Pratt Stuart
Ragard Lawrence
Rosenbaum Jennifer
Sanchez Demaris
Schuman Shari
Steward Mark
Waterman Mary Beth
Umbel Keith
Ferrantello Donna
Hasson Marsha A
Bridgeman Beth
Martinusen Ellen
Sabastianelli Mary
Miller Amy
Menacker Fay
Miedzinski Mollie
Miesko Lindsay
Lease Cathy
Rinehart Melinda
Agamir Maks
Awatramani Kamla
Barbee John
Barlow William Christopher
Beach Donna
Bradley Barbara
Brenner Karen
Butler Lois
Bristor Joel
Caughman Clifford
Chanapatna Ramachandra
Cranson Linda
Desir Jerry
Donegan Katheryn
Fleming John
Florczyk Michael
Galyon Jeff
Gordon Christopher
Han Cheol
Havel Bobbie
Hendricks Aubrey
Hickman Donna
Ho Maggie
Jackson Elizabeth
Kahane Dalia C
Khan Asia
Laio Mei
Lee Annabelle
Lott Ben
Lucas-Mudd Donna
Moore Diane
Morgan Alan
Neagu Gabriel
Ohan Peter
Revzin Margarita
Rychlec Joseph
Samiel Reza
Siford Erin
Simons Desiree
Smith Matthew
Swei Liyun
Theodorou Elias
Vakhlis Aleksandr
Walsh Judith H
Wenzel Blaine
Whitlock Marianne
Williamson Steve
Wu Maureen
Yang Cheng-Lan
Yoda Sekou
Williamson Steve
Wu Maureen
Myers Max H
Young Paul A
Lewis Denise A R
Francis Robert W
Saunders Lori A
Signes Carmita
Scheck Susan
Lake William
Riley Thomas
Austin Joe
Erwin Diane E
Flynn Doug
Mabie Jerome E
Clapp Jonathan D
Moore Matthew R
Xu FangFang
Jones Gordon C
Rathmell Joshua M
Williams Craig R
Young Michael
Goodman Andrew
Hickey Thomas P
Commins John M
Wright Patrick
Shaul Sally K
Crawford E David
Ogden Sheryl L
Tenorio Sally
Fyles Peggy
Golz Diane
Hommel Stacy
McCormick Deborah
Pashleigh Gale
Slimak Nancy
Turner Nancy
Ayodeji Nicole Green
Josse Denise
McAfee Julie
Meskimen Eric
Pennington Jenny
Suchey Wendy
Ali-Ahmadi Mashal
Barnett Amy Wheeler
Brothers Jennifer
Chronister Nicole Davis
Cipolla Danielle
Crawford Ryan
Chun Sung
Gebhart Karina
Hunter Helen
Hernandez Jhenny
Patel Kanak
Poage Wendy
Pozzetta Meegan
Simms Shayna
Swingler Jeff
Taylor Cory
Turner Marie
Wallack Ariana
Curtis Kathleen
Pierce Darlene
Borrego Patricia Vallejos
Rundus Chris
Bonde Eloise
Gamito Eduard
Pretzel Shannon
Dahmer Joanne
Deines Terri
Geske Monica
Holladay Marcia
Jackson Helen
Jordan Tammy
Ordonez Eda
Beechum Tia
Crawford Marc
Dittmer Kristi
Donohue Alicia
Garcia Felicia
Giese Scott
Kleinfield Amy
Kleinman Melissa
Moss Wendy
Motomiya Kayo
Murken Roger
Neel Dana
Razook Carrington
Shoaga Ali
Thompson Andrew
Vargas Stephanie
Lynch David
O'Driscoll Martin
Townsend Ron
Stamm Elizabeth
Drose Julia
Davidson Susan
Ahnen Dennis
Levine Joel
Murchison William
Steinberg Steve
Gelmann Edward P
Isaacs Claudine
McGuire Colleen
Trocky Nina
Bourdeau Christopher
Ke Polly
Martino Laura
Apostolides Ipatia
Elbon-Copp Constance
Klemm Kimberly
Lippman Catherine
Klotz Carol
McLaurin Tanita
Williams Tanja
Ginyard Johnsonette
Cantrell Sara
Marsh Gigi
Tran Amy
Wray Chrispina
Yondonsambu Baigalmaa
Taddeo Ciro
Bennett Kathleen
Bowen Tracy
English Kathryn
Seaton Kimberly
Hammond Tiffanie
Ford Morgan
Newman Kate
Kren Meg
English Nancy
McKenzie Dianne
Yokochi Lance A
Gilbert Fred
Curb David
Kessel Bruce
Navin James
Petrovich Helen
Shambaugh Vicki
Tabrah Frank
Waitzfelder Beth
Willcox Bradley
Jenkins Victoria
Chasnoff Rachelle
Vander Does Joanne
Martin Jamaal
Ideta Barbara
Stryker Kim
Batangan Elsie
Dolan Liz
Horton Kristin
Taylor Karen
Tokumine Ted
Troyer Rebecca
Barrow Sarah
Hayashida Susan
Commander Shirley
Turner Louisa
Hino Gladys
Nakano Esther
Johnson Myrle
Villaruz Lilian
Chung Anne
Huynh William
Hickey Nika
Calulot Marilyn
Chun Victoria
Lewis Cheryl
Morfit June
Tani Joy
Banggo Kathy
Brunst Amy
Francis Wendy
Grove Leslie
Holderbaum Brooke
Kinney Kim
O'Sullivan Teresa
Rowan-Lau Peggy
Bow Kathleen
Shiratori Helene
Tsukamoto Jean
Hodges Helene
Hyun Shirleen
Kuiee Julia
Lucente Lori
Oshiro Pat
Shota Kathy
Kvale Paul A
Demers Raymond
Fogel Ronald
Rutt Wilmer
Bresalier Robert S
Johnson Christine Cole
Lamerato Lois
Broski Karen
Ford Marvella E
LaFata Jennifer Elston
McCarthy Bruce
Ward Richard
Andrews Tara
Day Margie
Flickinger Lynn M
Hantz Teresa
Talley Dorothea
Wilson Diana
Blount Angela
Tammemagi C Martin
Barr Claudia
Hall Timothy
Haykus Wendy
Stanifer Sherrie
Baker Patricia
Montague Rita
Day Charlotte
Nanovski Anna
Hill Cynthia
Boles Teresa
Witherspoon Audrey
Banks Gina
Green Karen
Bernardin Kathy
Kozlowski Paul
Wells Jan
Salisbury Holly
Shepard Anne
McKeeman Jackie
Jeffery Tonya
Castor Cherice
Boswell Markieta
Gardner Mylitta
Hooker Claire
Maddy Noel
Morris Juanita
Mototolea Dojna
Berlicz Judith
Bonds Tavia
Fountain Shelley
Williams Millie
Djuric Boban
Szabo Nora
Cross Christine
Jagger Fran
Johnson Amena
McCarver Linda
Scharbonneau Melissa
Thomas Virginia
Norwood Marquetta
Mobley Madeline
Kokko SueAnn
Doute Darlene
Ciccoretti Karen
Wright Karen Wilkinson
Emmer Deborah
Shabazz Pamela
Leyson-Fiel Anna
Pratt Kathy
Bailey Mary
Alexander Toyia
Kok Joann LaBeau
Church Timothy R
Mandel Jack
Oken Martin M
Engelhard Deb
Cordes Jill
Geisser Mindy
Watt Gavin
Bradley Peggy
Hansen Carol
Kokubu Joshua
Lee Ryan
Palmquist Krista
Sigal Brad
Barnes Tanya
Fleishhacker Michelle
Grengs Jason
Hebner Shannon
Lewis Michael
Mendez AnaMaria
Miller Deanna
Nielsen Jennifer
Theis Lori
Ronan Rosalie
Rice Marianne
DesMarais Donna
Mongin Steve
Silverman Greg
Strahan Frank
Portnov Natalya
Sandley Nissa
Vuong Simone
Zirbes Aaron
Fredrickson Ann
Hoffbeck Richard
Murzyn Robert
Woodside Joseph
Beckmann Patricia
Boldt Mark
Jurjans Linda
Swenson Susan
Terrien Shirley
Fisher Jim
Breer Sophie
Collins Susan
Manuel Janet
Matous LeAnn
Muller Candace
Olsson Phyllis
Peterson Susan
Steele Mary Lynn
Tonnell Susan
Halverson Jennifer
Hanna Margaret
Hathaway-Ott Jan
Harper Betty
Hunter Helen
Lindall-Hawkins Judy
Longen Cathy
Nickelson Shirlyn
Overby Doris
Rodier MaryAnn
Smith Barbara
Weiner Virginia
Haselhuhn Cheri
Heath Darlene
Julin Elaine
Naslund Laura Lee
Skytta Carla
Warren Deborah
Clement Mary
Michels Nita
Swavely DeeAnn
Sitarz Jann
Thomas JoAnn
Steinberg Carol
Sielaff Timothy
Watry Marge
Fraki Sally
Burrell Jeff
Sandell Linda
Andriole Gerald L
Lowery Adelheid A
Charlton Elaine
Desai Ann
Gardner Vivien
Stanczak Debbie
Taylor Kathy
Freesmeier Elaine
Civitelli Karen
Ehrhard Katherine
Nieters Patricia
Hilke Cindy
Phillips Kate
Robinson Wanda
Wehde Michelle
Branam Carol
Freesmeier Kristin
Kane Candy
Murphey Sharon
Royal Dave
Scire Joann
Bickford Kelly
Fleming Elizabeth
Goforth Julie
Graham Deborah
Montani Jane
Naughton Kate
Palumbo Becky
Sicard-Su Jayne
Blanke Rita
Cashel Pat
DeFord Kelly
Liddy Kourtney
Lieberoff Angela
Nelson Karen
Reismeyer Lisa
Ritter Barb
Robertson Shelly
Standbrook Shelly
Stilts Darlene
Webb Janise
Garrett Kathy
Laster Sydney
Stolin Celia
Bullock Arnold
Grubb Robert
Levitt Robert
Middleton Mary
McKnight Robert
James William
Weinstock Leonard
Thyssen Erik
Fleshman James
Mutch Matthew
Carter-Replog Angela
Mutch David
Gray Diana
Weissfeld Joel L
Hill Lyndon
Hakala Thomas
Guido Richard
Fuhrman Carl
Overly Wylie
Proctor Julian W
Schoen Robert E
Sulecki Matthew
Trombetta Mark
Gahagan Betsy
Bonk Janet
Yagjian Mary
Gitchel Roni
Sufka Pam
McDonough Kathleen
Carl Kathleen
Gongloff Janet
Karl Terry
Lucas Carol
Lytle Lynn
Sibbet Marcia
Weinstein Judy
Coopie Betty
Dyjak Lucinda
Johnson Lettie
Kielty Jan
Landis Ginny
Misko Sue
Oleson Peggy
Ritman Mary
Clement Lisa
Danvers Ann
Riley Mary Alyce
Buys Saundra S
Gren Lisa H
Childs Jeffery
Andersen Adriane
Bacon Jennifer
Bossi Marie
Briscoe Laura
Broschinsky Mark
Callahan Bill
Conner Thomas
Ernst Jenni
Fischer Rachel
Gregersen Jeremy
Hamatake Nickolas
Hamatake Chris
Henrichsen Amity
lhler Nikole
Jensen Lesli
Jones Kara
Killian Lindsay
Liddle Mindy
Lochner Mary
Monaco Alie
Morreal Robert
Nate Amy
Nolan Kimberly
Olson Cassie
Park Andee
Ricks Shannon
Sheltra Scott
Stewart Alina
Sturges Lisa
Sullenger Julie
Taylor Kristi
Toyn Chris
Van Stam Eduard
Argyle Neil
Christensen Jeff
Bennett Sue
Biggs Jeremy
Branson Donna
Bryson Melanie
Childs Brandon
Dalton Cherie
Doi Brian
Doi Jenifer
Foss Susan
Gudgell Paulina
Hicks Linda
Hsu Polly
LaMay Devon
Montalbo Chani
Newman Linda
Randall Anne
Thompson Judy
Schliep Karen
Stanfield Kasey
Watson Darcy
Newman Linda
Reese Marcia
Whittaker Brianne
Whittaker Nathan
Wicklander Eddy
Wolf Jake
Varner Julie
Bennett Niela
Bonoacci Michele
Harper Angela
Reay Sandra
McFadden Kathleen
O'Toole Karen
Butcher Toni
Walker Darrelle
Richardson Johathan
Hong Howard
Lund Barbara
Rowley Jennifer
Tlachac Jon
VanRy John
Walker Crystal
Hamilton Blake
Labasky Richard
Landau Stewart
Middleton Richard
Stephenson Robert
Beck Thomas M
Sturges Lisa
Wohlers Bonita
Berreth Kathy
Roberts Pamela
Carter Patricia
Goodman Dawn
Hagerman Gena
Hon Tiffany
Marshock Janette
Martin Rolanda
Burke Louis
Seifert Avery L
Reding Douglas
Greenlee Robert
Hocking William
Lappe Karen
Multerer Deborah
Fischer Virginia
Heiting Juline C
Mueller Cathy
Mathiesen-Viergutz Kay
Bohman Kari
Carey Laurel
Vieth Amy
Aue Kelly
Kriescher Denise
Miller Claudia
Thums Norma
Wein Sheila
Kofka Karen
Luttropp Karen
Mueller Camille
Dix Brenda
Mueller Lin
Swensen Kathy
Wachholz Shirley
Kramer Ranae
Bright Becky
Zahradka Sue
Fouad Mona
Oberman Albert
Partridge Edward
Urban Donald
Kiefe Catarina
Shikany James
Higgins Darlene
Thompson Joanice
Johnson Mel
Moore Alisha
Powell Beverly
McCoy Billy
Oden Christie
Khatri Rekha
Pike Margaret
Buring J E
Alberts D
Carter H B
Chodak G
Hawk E
Malm H
Mayer R J
Piantadosi S
Silvestri G A
Thompson I M
Westhoff C L
Kahn J P
Levin B
DeMets D
O'Fallon J R
Porter A T
Ashton M M
Black W C
Albertsen P C
Edmonson J H
Lawrence W
Fontana R
Rajput A
Miller A B
Eisenberger M
Jatoi I
Glatstein E
Welch H G
References (27)
27 references, click to expand
-
NCCN clinical practice guidelines in oncology: prostate cancer early detection.
J Natl Compr Canc Netw. 2010 Feb;8(2):240-62
PMID: 20141680
-
Complications of transrectal ultrasound-guided systematic sextant biopsies of the prostate: evaluation of complication rates and risk factors within a population-based screening program.
Urology. 1997 Jun;49(6):875-80
PMID: 9187694
-
Etiologic and early marker studies in the prostate, lung, colorectal and ovarian (PLCO) cancer screening trial.
Control Clin Trials. 2000 Dec;21(6 Suppl):349S-355S
PMID: 11189687
-
30-day mortality and major complications after radical prostatectomy: influence of age and comorbidity.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2005 Oct 19;97(20):1525-32
PMID: 16234566
-
Lead times and overdetection due to prostate-specific antigen screening: estimates from the European Randomized Study of Screening for Prostate Cancer.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2003 Jun 18;95(12):868-78
PMID: 12813170
-
Population-based study of relationships between hospital volume of prostatectomies, patient outcomes, and length of hospital stay.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1999 Nov 17;91(22):1950-6
PMID: 10564679
-
Infection after transrectal core biopsies of the prostate--risk factors and antibiotic prophylaxis.
Br J Urol. 1996 Jun;77(6):851-5
PMID: 8705220
-
Studies of prostate-cancer mortality: caution advised.
Lancet Oncol. 2008 May;9(5):407-9
PMID: 18452850
-
Prostate Cancer Screening in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian (PLCO) Cancer Screening Trial: findings from the initial screening round of a randomized trial.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2005 Mar 16;97(6):433-8
PMID: 15770007
-
The role of increasing detection in the rising incidence of prostate cancer.
JAMA. 1995 Feb 15;273(7):548-52
PMID: 7530782
-
Design of the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian (PLCO) Cancer Screening Trial.
Control Clin Trials. 2000 Dec;21(6 Suppl):273S-309S
PMID: 11189684
-
Benefits and harms of prostate-specific antigen screening for prostate cancer: an evidence update for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.
Ann Intern Med. 2008 Aug 5;149(3):192-9
PMID: 18678846
-
Prostate cancer screening in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian cancer screening trial: update on findings from the initial four rounds of screening in a randomized trial.
BJU Int. 2008 Dec;102(11):1524-30
PMID: 19035857
-
Screening for prostate cancer: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommendation statement.
Ann Intern Med. 2008 Aug 5;149(3):185-91
PMID: 18678845
-
Quality of life: radical prostatectomy versus radiation therapy for prostate cancer.
J Urol. 1995 Oct;154(4):1420-5
PMID: 7658548
-
Health outcomes after external-beam radiation therapy for clinically localized prostate cancer: results from the Prostate Cancer Outcomes Study.
J Clin Oncol. 2001 May 1;19(9):2517-26
PMID: 11331331
-
Screening and prostate-cancer mortality in a randomized European study.
N Engl J Med. 2009 Mar 26;360(13):1320-8
PMID: 19297566
-
20-year outcomes following conservative management of clinically localized prostate cancer.
JAMA. 2005 May 4;293(17):2095-101
PMID: 15870412
-
Death review process in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian (PLCO) Cancer Screening Trial.
Control Clin Trials. 2000 Dec;21(6 Suppl):400S-406S
PMID: 11189691
-
Androgen deprivation therapy for localized prostate cancer and the risk of cardiovascular mortality.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2007 Oct 17;99(20):1516-24
PMID: 17925537
-
The Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian (PLCO) Cancer Screening Trial of the National Cancer Institute: history, organization, and status.
Control Clin Trials. 2000 Dec;21(6 Suppl):251S-272S
PMID: 11189683
-
Screening decreases prostate cancer mortality: 11-year follow-up of the 1988 Quebec prospective randomized controlled trial.
Prostate. 2004 May 15;59(3):311-8
PMID: 15042607
-
Prostate biopsy following a positive screen in the prostate, lung, colorectal and ovarian cancer screening trial.
J Urol. 2005 Mar;173(3):746-50; discussion 750-1
PMID: 15711261
-
Five-year outcomes after prostatectomy or radiotherapy for prostate cancer: the prostate cancer outcomes study.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 2004 Sep 15;96(18):1358-67
PMID: 15367568
-
Radical prostatectomy versus watchful waiting in early prostate cancer.
N Engl J Med. 2005 May 12;352(19):1977-84
PMID: 15888698
-
Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) best practice policy. American Urological Association (AUA).
Oncology (Williston Park). 2000 Feb;14(2):267-72, 277-8, 280 passim
PMID: 10736812
-
The impact of androgen deprivation on quality of life after radical prostatectomy for prostate carcinoma.
Cancer. 2002 Jul 15;95(2):287-95
PMID: 12124828